Canada’s job numbers barely treading water

This week’s GDP numbers confirmed that Canada experienced a recession in the first six months of 2015 and today’s latest job numbers show Canadians looking for steady, good jobs have been feeling the pinch.

During the month of August, Canada created 12,000 new jobs – switching out 42,000 part-time jobs for 54,000 full-time jobs. The unemployment rate increased 0.2 percentage points to 7%.

The real concern here is that the employment rate of 15-64 year olds has not yet returned to pre-recession levels. And job creation has barely kept up with population growth.

In fact, Canada needs to create almost 240,000 new jobs in order to regain the September 2008 employment rate of 73.5%. The current employment rate of 72.5% is hovering around the same level as early 2013 (the previous post-recession peak).

Source: Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, CANSIM Table 282-0087.  Population aged 15-64, figures are seasonally adjusted
Source: Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, CANSIM Table 282-0087. Population aged 15-64, figures are seasonally adjusted

On the election trail, Stephen Harper has been suggesting that the decline in GDP has been contained in the oil and gas sector. But several other key industries that should be doing better are also in recession.

Today’s job numbers clearly show recession has led to employment stagnation in other sectors as well, including Canada’s long-suffering manufacturing sector and, surprisingly, construction.

The numbers also show Alberta’s not the only province hurting. Across the country, only four provinces saw substantial job gains in the first eight months of 2015.

Alberta has certainly seen a decline oil and gas jobs, but since December 2014 the province has actually seen employment stagnate as those oil and gas jobs are replaced with jobs in the services sector including retail and wholesale trade and health care and social assistance. Prince Edward Island, New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and Saskatchewan have all seen declines in employment since December 2014. Clearly the job losses have not been contained in Alberta.

Job growth in 10 out of 16 industries either stagnated or declined in the first eight months of 2015. The stagnating and declining industries represent 60% of all jobs in Canada. And three of the six sectors where we see employment growth are supported by the public sector: health care and social assistance, educational services, and utilities have all seen job gains so far this year. Without those sectors, Canada’s job stagnation would be a lot worse.

The big surprise in the table below is that manufacturing jobs have stagnated at a time when many economists thought conditions were right for growth. The decline in the dollar was widely expected to have attracted manufacturers back to Canada – particularly Ontario. But that has not played out in the jobs numbers, nor in the GDP figures. The manufacturing sector’s job creation has stagnated, even as the U.S. economy strengthens and exports continue to grow – though that export growth appears to have come from an unusually large shipment of precious metals to the U.S. in July.

Job Growth by major industry, first 8 month of 2015
Industry Change since December 2014
Growing
Utilities 2.70%
Transportation and warehousing 2.80%
Finance, insurance, real estate and leasing 1.20%
Professional, scientific and technical services 3.80%
Educational services 2.90%
Health care and social assistance 1.90%
Stagnating
Manufacturing 0.50%
Trade 0.80%
Business, building and other support services 0.10%
In Decline
Agriculture -5.30%
Forestry, fishing, mining, quarrying, oil and gas -5.60%
Construction -1.80%
Information, culture and recreation -1.50%
Accommodation and food services -0.70%
Other services -1.10%
Public administration -1.10%
 Source: Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, CANSIM Table 282-0094, Figures are seasonally adjusted

Nowhere in Canada was the drop in the loonie supposed to have had a more positive impact than in Ontario. But, as I pointed out last month, that has not been the case for manufacturing jobs. And the data shows that job creation in the manufacturing sector remains stagnant in the first eight months of 2015.

Source: Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, CANSIM Table 282-0088, Figures are seasonally adjusted
Source: Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, CANSIM Table 282-0088, Figures are seasonally adjusted

No wonder The Economist called Ontario the new rust belt of North America, pointing to scenes of “industrial decay” along the Niagara peninsula and southwestern Ontario.

Yesterday, TD Bank released a great report to help us understand the mechanisms behind this failure to launch.

Today’s numbers show that Ontario created 56,800 new jobs so far this year — swapping out 78,800 part-time for 135,500 full-time. At the same time, the unemployment rate has jumped up to 6.8% — that’s 0.4 percentage points higher than last month.

That Ontario’s unemployment rate is lower than the national average is being heralded as a beacon of hope by some, but it masks the fact that Ontario alone needs to create almost 130,000 new jobs in order to reach pre-recession employment rate of workers age 15-64.

One bright spot on the national job scene this month is a slight increase in the participation rate, possibly indicating that people are seeing hope in the jobs market.

When it comes to jobs, Canada is still struggling with a hangover from the previous recession. The share of Canada’s part-time workers who would rather be working full-time continues to sit above 26%. Prior to the 2008-09 recession that number had fallen to below 22%.

Temporary work in Canada has increased slightly over pre-2008-09 recession levels as well —though it has come down from its 2012 peak. Long-term unemployment in Canada has held steady at around 20% since 2012 as well.

But nationally, real median hourly wages have stagnated.

A large share of these trends is being driven by Ontario.

Ontario is home to more than one third of the electoral districts in Canada. And the province has remained a hot spot for all the three major party leaders as they campaign across the country.

As we move through this election season, it’s time to stop debating the semantics of this most recent recession — where it occurred and who it affected — and start talking about how to achieve a thriving labour market recovery with good jobs and stability for all.

Of course we at the CCPA have some ideas for how to make that happen: visit our GoodforCanada.ca platform to end income inequality. It’s an excellent place to start.

Kaylie Tiessen is an economist with the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives’ Ontario Office. Follow her on Twitter: @KaylieTiessen

One comment

  1. And now Harper is ignoring job numbers because he’s now spun out a 2014-15 surplus year. I suspect it was spun like the miller’s daughter who spun gold out of straw–but we’ll never know who acted as Rumplestilskin for the PMO.

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Before commenting, please read our Comment Policy