The Race To The Trough: What Did Corporate Tax Cuts Deliver?

The CLC today celebrated Corporate Tax Freedom Day – defined as the day on which corporations have paid their share of all government taxes.  It featured a race of mechanical pigs to a trough full of cash – with the pigs wearing the colours of leading Canadian corporations with large cash reserves. Watch the video.

The winner? Potash Corporation of Saskatchewan  with over $5 Billion of surplus cash on its books at the end of 2010 (and that was after a $2 Billion purchase of their own shares.)

The background paper was written by David Macdonald and myself. The summary follows. And there was an op ed from CLC President Ken Georgetti in the Toronto Star today

Here is the Summary:

Due to ongoing corporate tax cuts, corporate income taxes make up a falling share of all government revenues. In fact, by the end of January, corporations will have fully paid their share of taxes.

The general federal corporate income tax rate stood at 28% in 2000. It was cut to 21% under the Liberals, and then cut in stages, from 21% to 15%, under the Conservatives. The most recent cut was from 16.5% to 15%, effective January 1, 2012.

Each one percentage point cut to the corporate income tax rate costs the federal government about $2 billion in annual revenues.

The argument for corporate income tax cuts has been that increased after-tax corporate profits would be re-invested in company operations, boosting economic growth, productivity, and jobs. However, studies have shown that rising corporate after-tax profits have not resulted in increased real investment.

This study looks at the profits and investments of Canada’s largest companies, those listed on the S&P/TSX Composite Index, from 2000 to 2010.

In line with cuts to the statutory federal and provincial tax rate, the effective tax rate (that is, taxes actually paid by Canada’s largest companies to the federal and provincial governments as a share of pretax profits) has fallen from one third in the early 2000s (35% in 2000), to between one fifth and one quarter (24% in 2010).

Companies have used increased after-tax profits to boost dividends paid out to their shareholders. Dividends as a percentage of after-tax profits have risen from 30% in 2000 to over 50% in recent years.

Companies have also chosen to retain higher after-tax profits as financial assets, as cash, and as longer term assets, not counting investments in capital stock.

The study looks at the change in the assets of Canada’s largest non-financial companies. (Financial companies and conglomerates are excluded because they typically hold large financial investments as part of their ongoing business.)

The Top-10 Corporate Hoarders have collectively accumulated $30.7 billion in extra short- and long-term assets between 2000 and 2010, since 2000.  The leading cash hoarder has been Potash Corporation of Saskatchewan, which accumulated over $5 billion in assets over this period.

The Appendix lists Canada’s top Corporate Hoarders.

Cuts to corporate taxes have resulted in a major loss of government revenues, without the anticipated result of higher corporate investment in machinery and equipment, new plants, and other areas of company operations. Instead, we have seen a big increase in dividend payouts and in financial assets.

2 comments

  1. Good work on this report. It really hits home that these cuts aren’t going into investments and that the reduced revenue from corporate taxes isn’t being made up for by increased revenues elsewhere.

Leave a Reply to slantendicular Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Before commenting, please read our Comment Policy